Best Everton Premier League XI

Selecting the best-ever Everton team from the Premier League era involves combining players from different eras based on their performances, impact, and contributions to the club. Here's a lineup that could be considered among the best, arranged in a traditional 4-4-2 formation:

Goalkeeper: Neville Southall - Even though his peak years were in the late 1980s, Southall's experience and quality were invaluable in the early Premier League years.
Right-Back: Seamus Coleman - A consistent performer and a leader on the pitch, Coleman has been a key figure in Everton's defense for many years.
Center-Back: Dave Watson - A stalwart in defense, Watson's leadership and defensive qualities were pivotal in the early Premier League days.
Center-Back: Phil Jagielka - Jagielka's reliability, defensive prowess, and memorable goals, including his long-range strikes, make him a standout choice.
Left-Back: Leighton Baines - Known for his crossing ability, set-piece expertise, and attacking prowess, Baines has been one of Everton's most consistent performers.
Right Midfield: Andrei Kanchelskis - Though his time at Everton was brief, Kanchelskis made a significant impact with his pace and scoring ability.
Center Midfield: Mikel Arteta - Arteta's technical ability, vision, and creativity in the midfield were crucial for Everton.
Center Midfield: Tim Cahill - More of an attacking midfielder, Cahill was known for his aerial ability, scoring crucial goals, and his passionate celebrations.
Left Midfield: Steven Pienaar - Pienaar's skill, work rate, and partnership with Baines down the left flank were vital to Everton's play style.
Striker: Duncan Ferguson - A cult hero at Everton, Ferguson's physical presence and heading ability made him a formidable striker.
Striker: Romelu Lukaku - Lukaku's goal-scoring record at Everton was impressive, making him one of the best strikers in the club's Premier League history.

Substitutes could include players like Tim Howard (GK), Gary Speed (MF), and Richarlison (FW), who also had significant impacts during their time at Everton.

This lineup combines different eras and styles, reflecting some of the best talents Everton has seen in the Premier League era. Remember, such selections can be subjective and may vary based on personal preferences and interpretations of the term "best".